Shared Leads vs. Exclusive Leads: Which is Right for Your Home Service Business

Shared Leads vs. Exclusive Lead Generation: What Home Service Business Owners Should Know

If you’ve ever paid for a lead and then found out that three other contractors had the same one then you know why this is such a big deal. Lead generation is one of the biggest line items in a home service business budget and the type of lead you’re buying has a massive impact on your cost per lead, your close rates and your sanity.

Here’s how shared and exclusive leads compare and how you can work out which is right for your business.

What are Shared Leads?

Shared leads are sold to several businesses at once and the home service companies then contact the customer and try to win the bid. These leads are normally generated when a homeowner fills in a form asking for a quote on a specific home service like roofing for example and that one lead goes to three, four, five roofer’s at the same time.

There are quite a few upsides to buying shared leads including:

  • Shared leads are normally much cheaper per lead.
  • You can get a very high volume of leads very quickly.
  • They’re a good way to test out a new service area or to fill in any gaps in your schedule.

and the downside includes:

  • You’re directly competing with your competitors for the same exact leads.
  • The first to call usually wins.
  • Homeowners get inundated with calls and texts and many just stop answering.
  • Price becomes the key selling point and that in turn squeezes your margins.
  • Your CLO is generally lower so the low price per lead can be very misleading.

What are Exclusive Leads?

Exclusive leads go to one business only. The customer is either contacting you directly through or being matched with you exclusively through lead generation methods like pay per call. That covers calls coming in via your Google Business Profile, Local Services Ads, your website forms and referrals.

The upside to exclusive leads are:

  • No competition for that particular one.
  • The customer is more likely to pick up and have a real conversation.
  • You can concentrate on building trust rather than being the first to market.
  • Close rates are typically higher.

The downside:

  • The cost per lead is significantly higher.
  • You still need to follow up promptly.

Cheaper leads aren’t necessarily cheaper. The number that really matters is what you pay to win a customer. So track your close rate by lead source before you make any decisions about where your budget should go.

Shared or exclusive leads; which should you choose?

This all depends on where your business stands when your ready to start investing.

Shared leads may make more sense if:

  • You’ve got a fast response system and can call back in minutes.
  • You’re a lower priced operator who competes very well on speed and price.
  • You’ve got to fill your calendar as quickly as possible.

Exclusive leads may make sense if:

  • You sell high end services where trust is key.
  • Your team is small and you simply can’t chase dozens of leads a day.
  • You want to build a brand rather than just compete on price.

For most home service businesses the best approach is a hybrid one. Make Google Local Services Ads your primary lead source, as they often deliver some of the highest-quality, highest-intent leads for home service businesses, then use shared leads or exclusive leads to add additional volume when needed.

How to Get the Most From Your Leads

Whether your buying shared leads or exclusive leads, you will be wasting your money if your not prepared to handle the call volume these services can produce. To be successful, make sure your business can:

  • Respond quickly. Speed is important with both of them, but absolutely critical when buying shared leads.
  • Track everything! Know your cost per lead, your close rate and your cost per job by source.
  • Ask for reviews. Good reviews will help you to win the shared leads and will also generate more of the exclusive ones.
  • Relentlessly dispute bad leads. Seriously, pay attention to the leads and make sure you listen to the recordings of your calls to ensure your lead quality is solid.
  • Review monthly. Lead quality will change and what worked last quarter may well not work this quarter.

Final Thoughts

At the end of the day, the best leads are the ones that work best for your business. Shared leads are cheaper but more competitive. Exclusive leads cost more but are far easier to close. Neither is automatically better. The right choice comes down to your close rate, your capacity, and how well you follow up. Run the numbers, test both, and put more budget behind whichever one actually fills your schedule with profitable jobs.

Related Posts